Sneakers are a near-constant purchase for me and a frequent source of frustration. It’s hard enough to find the perfect pair to cover as many comfortable miles as possible, but then, each year, that sneaker model changes dramatically. These updated versions usually don’t resemble or perform as well as the previous, beloved year’s model. Getting outside opinions can further complicate things since everyone’s needs and preferences are so different. I hit this issue every 200 miles.

I’ve rotated between a few different models of Brooks and ASICS for many years. While there’s a lot to love about the Brooks brand, the quality of the models I was getting each year reduced to the point where I was even getting toe holes (Glycerin 20) in each pair before 90 miles.

I have not experienced this quality dip with ASICS and have grown to prefer their gel insoles–it’s a difference that can be felt immediately. But their Gel-Kayano model was making my underpronation (insufficient inward roll of the foot after landing) worse, and the latest model has become nearly identical to Hokas, which I’ve found overly bulky and unstable.

It all feels impossible and overly expensive until I remember to just go to the local runner’s store. I brought in my old shoes so they could look at my treadwear pattern, and I shared brand preferences and activity goals. I walked away with a pair of ASICS Gel-Cumulus 26, which feel like they will be perfect—for now.